South Africa’s proposed 20% online gambling tax has sparked widespread concern among industry stakeholders, with calls for the Treasury to carefully assess its potential impact before proceeding with the proposed changes.
Sean Coleman, Chief Executive Officer of the South African Bookmakers Association (SABA), has questioned whether the Treasury has adequately assessed the country’s existing tax burden as it considers introducing a nationwide tax on online gambling Gross Gaming Revenue (GGR).
During the stakeholder consultation on the proposed national tax, SABA called on the Treasury to withdraw the proposed 20% tax and instead establish a technical working group and data-sharing framework to guide the process.
The association also emphasised the need for independent cumulative tax, market channelisation and gambling harm modelling before any legislation is advanced.
SABA clarified that it does not advocate leaving the gambling industry without oversight. Instead, it urged the Treasury to ensure that any intervention in the sector is guided by “evidence and measurable outcomes”.
The consultation brought together several industry stakeholders, many of whom expressed similar concerns about the potential consequences of introducing aggressive taxation without sufficient supporting evidence.
Industry Warns of Regulated Market Leakage
Laurence Michel, Chairman of Betway Africa, warned that excessive taxation could eventually reach a point where it generates little additional revenue while pushing players and operators away from the regulated market towards unlicensed offshore platforms.
He pointed to experiences in the Netherlands, the UK and, more notably, Kenya, where increased taxation has raised concerns about regulated market participation and government tax revenue.
In Kenya, several regulated operators have exited the market following changes in the tax environment. Michel cautioned that South Africa should avoid a similar outcome.
“South Africa can’t afford to drive more gamblers into an already thriving illegal market here,” he warned.
Drawing from his own experience in Kenya, Michel explained that Betway had previously operated in the market before eventually withdrawing.
“We’ve seen that in Kenya. We were actually a participant in the Kenyan market at that point. We actually left. You know, we picked up our tools, and we employed about 100 people, and we left. Who benefited? Who benefited? Nobody.”
Michel stressed that policymakers should first understand the available data, assess the potential impact and then develop an appropriate taxation framework before moving towards implementation and regulation.
He also highlighted the importance of collaboration between government authorities and industry stakeholders, arguing that the process should not become a confrontation between the National Gambling Board and operators or between the Treasury and the industry.
“We all need each other,” he emphasised.
Virgin Bet Raises Concerns Over Taxation and Revenue Collection
Garron Whitesman, the attorney representing Virgin Bet, also drew comparisons with European markets that have experienced increases in gambling taxation.
He warned that there were already clear examples of the consequences of imposing tax rates that are disproportionately high and punitive for the industry.
“Our view, and I say this of myself as well as my client Virgin Bet, is that the proposed tax is not rational, reasonable, or well-founded,” Whitesman stated.
He further questioned the lack of empirical evidence supporting the Treasury’s stated objectives of generating additional revenue for the national fiscus while mitigating problem gambling.
“There’s no empirical evidence that has been provided by Treasury to support Treasury’s stated policy objectives of the collection of additional taxes for the central fiscus and the mitigation of problem gambling.”
Whitesman also warned that the proposed tax could ultimately undermine the very revenue base the government seeks to expand.
“You’re proposing to collect taxes in one way, but you’re going to cause a complete erosion of your tax base as far as collectable taxes are concerned on withholding taxes, corporate tax, employee taxes, and the like.”
Concerns Over the Cumulative Tax Burden
Beyond the proposed nationwide 20% tax, stakeholders have also raised concerns about how the additional levy would interact with existing provincial gambling taxes, which range between 6% and 15%.
This could result in effective tax rates ranging from approximately 26% to 35%, depending on the applicable provincial rate.
Industry stakeholders fear that the cumulative tax burden could place further pressure on licensed operators, potentially affecting market competitiveness, investment and channelisation rates.
As discussions continue, the central question remains whether South Africa can achieve its revenue and responsible gambling objectives without making the regulated market less attractive to operators and players.
For industry stakeholders, the priority is clear: taxation policy must be informed by reliable data, meaningful consultation and a proper assessment of its wider economic and regulatory consequences.
